Fordthought
  • Blog
  • Word of the Week
  • Dig Deeper

w/c 8.9.14 – Relativism

7/9/2014

 


The doctrine that knowledge, truth, and morality exist in relation to culture, society, or historical context, and are not absolute.

Picture
Picture
The word on the week two weeks ago was absolutism (read it here) and so now we turn to the opposite ethical viewpoint; relativism.

One could be forgiven for thinking that relativism is a modern phenomena, perhaps born in the “swinging 60s” when social attitudes towards a huge number of issues began to change. However it has roots that go back much further: As early as 450 B.C. Protagoras, a Presocratic Philosopher, is remembered for his relativist statement that “man is the measure of all things”. He argued that Humans create moral standards for themselves and he is hailed as the first cultural relativist (Fieser).


Picture
Another major contributor to the relativist position came a long time before the 1960s – Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) was a revolutionary thinker for his time. He shunned conventional views of religion and morality and adopted instead the radical opinion that the only measure of good was the outcome that brought about “the greatest happiness of the greatest number” and that this “is the measure of right and wrong” (Bentham). He threw out the received wisdom of absolute moral laws given by God (indeed he was an avowed atheist) or dictated by the monarch. His moral philosophy was further developed by J.S. Mill and later Sidgwick, Hare and Singer amongst others; these philosophers adapted the basic tenets of the theory to deal with various criticisms but all hold to the notion that there cannot be one moral rule for all situations.

Picture
So what about the swinging 60s? Well they did have a big influence upon another major relativist ethical theory; Situation Ethics. Thinkers such as J.A.T. Robinson and Joseph Fletcher recognised that society had become rather disillusioned with the seemingly inflexible ethics of Christianity. The story may well be apocryphal, but Fletcher was apparently inspired by talking to a Chicago cabbie who told him that “sometimes you just have to forget the rules and do the right thing!” These theologians focused on agape (unconditional love) as the only absolute and that all moral rules should be adapted and altered to ensure that agape is achieved.

So does relativism work? Well in general in does produce moral answers that are flexible and seemingly more compassionate. Students I teach often agree that real-life problems require an approach that is able to adapt and react to the situation. However the serious objection is that relativism is inconsistent and impossible to apply accurately; for example how does Bentham propose we accurately measure pleasure? How can Fletcher ensure all people are shown agape? Surely it is better to use a set rule that everyone knows in advance and furthermore can show no unintentional favoritism or bias?

Are you a moral relativist? Or are you more convinced by absolutism?


    Archives

    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Absolutism
    Agnostic
    Analogy
    Animal
    Apophatic
    A Priori
    Aquinas
    Article
    Assisted Dying
    Banking
    Bertrand Russell
    Book Review
    Buddhism
    Christianity
    Cosmological
    Covenant
    Dawkins
    Debate
    Design
    Diaspora
    Dig Deeper
    Dukkha
    Epiphany
    Equality
    Euthanasia
    Existentialism
    Fallacies
    False Dichotomy
    Family
    Fertility
    Genesis
    Hajj
    Higher Education
    Hindu
    Hinduism
    Holocaust
    Hospice
    Human Rights
    Human-rights
    Hume
    Islam
    ISRSA
    Judaism
    Justice
    JWT
    Lent
    Life After Death
    Love
    Martyr
    Messiah
    MOOC
    Narnia
    NDE
    News
    Nirvana
    Ontological
    Plato
    PPE
    Pro Choice
    Pro-Choice
    Pro Life
    Pro-Life
    Prophet
    Reformation
    Relativism
    Religion
    Rights
    Sabbath
    Science Vs Religion
    Secularisation
    Soul
    Sport
    Stewardship
    Surrogacy
    Teleological
    Temple
    Ten Commandments
    Theology
    Viability
    Via Negativa
    Vision
    Warfare
    Wittgenstein
    Word
    Word Of The Week
    Word-of-the-week

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos from sneakerdog, Steve Slater (Wildlife Encounters), Art4TheGlryOfGod, johndillon77, dustinj, Charlie Davidson, ineffable_pulchritude, LisaW123, jamee.khairul, Abode of Chaos, Dunleavy Family