Fordthought
  • Blog
  • Word of the Week
  • Dig Deeper

Word of the Week: W/C 08/06/15 - NDE

6/6/2015

 


A Near-Death-Experience (NDE) is reputed to take place in a small number of people on the brink of death and is recounted by a person on recovery. typically they recall features such as an out-of-body experience, a tunnel of light, feelings of peace and/or meeting family or Angelic beings.

Picture
Picture
Image: www.spiritscienceandmetaphysics.com
PictureImage: www.thirdeyeactivation.com
Many religions make claims about the existence of an immaterial, immortal soul that can survive our bodily death. This is known as dualism and is believed in by many religions such as Christianity, Hinduism, Islam and Sikhism. But can these beliefs be proved by science? Science has not been able to identify the location of the soul in the body despite attempts by philosophers such as Descartes to propose that it is contained somewhere within us (in Descartes’ case he argued that the soul interacted with the body through the pineal gland. This has obviously been dismissed by modern medicine). But what if there was a moment when the soul did become evident? Some believe this to be when people nearly die, the soul starts to leave the body and then returns (when they are resuscitated) with memory of its “journey” out of the body.

PictureImage: zalozba.intuicija.si
Many of these events have been analysed by psychologists such as Dr Raymond Moody, Dr Kenneth Ring and Amber Wells, who have interviewed hundreds of people who claim to have had such an experience. As a result of these interviews he came up with 15 ‘common experiences’ and, while no one had all 15, one of the most common experiences was that of meeting dead relatives. 

If NDEs are accepted as real, then people meeting those who have died can be seen as ‘proof’ that there is life after death.  In Moody’s study, nearly all of the patients felt that they both understood, and were no longer afraid of, death as they knew what would happen when they die. If NDEs are accepted as ‘true’, then consciousness after death does ‘prove’ life after death.

PictureImage: www.tophdgallery.com
On the other hand, this argument hinges upon the assumption that NDEs are ‘real’ and not induced by pharmacological, psychological or neurological issues.  Dr Susan Blackmore, a psychologist, may have explained one of the more common features in the study which was travelling down a tunnel to see a bright light.  She has suggested that, when dying, the cells on the outside edge of the cornea begin to shut down, while the sensitivity of the inner cells is increased by impulses from the brain; this could produce the effects described.  It could be argued that, given that our bodies are contain the same components, it is not surprising that people experience the same sensations when undergoing a traumatic experience such as nearly dying. If then, NDEs are not ‘real’ but merely in the mind of the person, then they cannot prove that there is life after death.

PictureImage: www.lazerhorse.org
But what about cases when the individual has an out-of-body exeprience? One such incidence was that of Pam Reynolds, a woman who had an out-of-body experience while clinically dead.  She was later able to describe a conversation in the operating room and the tools used to cut into her head. She should not have known this information as she was sedated at the time. Advocates such as Moody believe that this provides a strong reason to belief in life after death, especially when combined with other testimonies.  

On the other hand, while a good deal of NDEs imply the existence of an afterlife, people who claim to have experienced them are not  consistent in their description of that afterlife. Moody’s subjects were all American - a country that is culturally Christian (and even the non-religious would have knowledge of Christianity) - they describe meeting a being of light and dead relatives which is the traditional Christian idea of the afterlife.  However a student of Dr Kenneth Ring, Amber Wells, conducted a similar study to Moody using subjects who were from different countries.  Her results demonstrated that 70% of the group had an experience that supported the idea of reincarnation rather than a final destination of heaven. This would appear to imply that NDEs are influenced by cultural upbringing.  If cultural upbringing instils a belief in life after death, then the experience could not be proof of the afterlife, but merely a reflection of the cultural (or religious) beliefs of the subject.


In conclusion, if NDEs are real then they appear to advocate some form of dualism and also offer reasons to believe in the afterlife.  However, alternative psychological explanations for NDEs cast serious doubt upon this. What do you think?

    Archives

    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Absolutism
    Agnostic
    Analogy
    Animal
    Apophatic
    A Priori
    Aquinas
    Article
    Assisted Dying
    Banking
    Bertrand Russell
    Book Review
    Buddhism
    Christianity
    Cosmological
    Covenant
    Dawkins
    Debate
    Design
    Diaspora
    Dig Deeper
    Dukkha
    Epiphany
    Equality
    Euthanasia
    Existentialism
    Fallacies
    False Dichotomy
    Family
    Fertility
    Genesis
    Hajj
    Higher Education
    Hindu
    Hinduism
    Holocaust
    Hospice
    Human Rights
    Human-rights
    Hume
    Islam
    ISRSA
    Judaism
    Justice
    JWT
    Lent
    Life After Death
    Love
    Martyr
    Messiah
    MOOC
    Narnia
    NDE
    News
    Nirvana
    Ontological
    Plato
    PPE
    Pro Choice
    Pro-Choice
    Pro Life
    Pro-Life
    Prophet
    Reformation
    Relativism
    Religion
    Rights
    Sabbath
    Science Vs Religion
    Secularisation
    Soul
    Sport
    Stewardship
    Surrogacy
    Teleological
    Temple
    Ten Commandments
    Theology
    Viability
    Via Negativa
    Vision
    Warfare
    Wittgenstein
    Word
    Word Of The Week
    Word-of-the-week

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos from sneakerdog, Steve Slater (Wildlife Encounters), Art4TheGlryOfGod, johndillon77, dustinj, Charlie Davidson, ineffable_pulchritude, LisaW123, jamee.khairul, Abode of Chaos, Dunleavy Family