Fordthought
  • Blog
  • Word of the Week
  • Dig Deeper

Word of the week: w/c 24/11/14: False Dichotomy

23/11/2014

 




A fallacy in which only two limited alternatives are considered. whereas in reality there are other options available.

Picture
Picture
This term is part of a series of “word of the week” posts that focus on fallacies; logical errors in an argument. A false dichotomy is when someone makes a case and presents two opposing views, options or outcomes in such a way that they seem to be the only possibilities. If one is true, the other must be false or, if you do not accept the one then the other must be accepted. The reality in most cases is that there are many in-between and alternative options not just two mutually exclusive ones.

One famous example of this was George W Bush when he declared in September 2001 that “either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists":


Picture
To many this would be seen as an oversimplification of the situation; you could after all be an absolute pacifist who is not willing to take up arms against any one on ethical grounds and so you are with neither and against neither. You might be in favour of diplomatic negation with terrorists etc.

The false dichotomy remains a popular fallacy to utilise because it sounds dramatic and presents listeners with a stark choice (especially if accompanied with a reduction ad absurdum) that will only really offer one way forward. As philosophers and ethicists we need to be alert to its usage! 


One area that I have seen it used a lot recently is when debating the difficult issue of Euthanasia with my GCSE group. I have found false dichotomies being used by both the pro-choice and pro-life sides of the argument:
“You either have Euthanasia, which allows people to die pain-free and with dignity, or you have no Euthanasia and everyone suffers intolerably and with a total loss of dignity” (Pro-Choice)

“If you allow Euthanasia then everyone will be killed as soon as they become terminally ill or over 70 years old – all valuing of life will be lost. Whereas, without a Euthanasia law the terminally ill are cherished and valued by society – which would you rather have?” (Pro-life) 

Both of these arguments are flawed in that they offer a false dichotomy – the first ignores the fantastic work that palliative care can do, the second overstates (performs a reductio) what might happen if Euthanasia was legalised.

So, See if you can spot a false dichotomy this week!
Picture

    Archives

    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Absolutism
    Agnostic
    Analogy
    Animal
    Apophatic
    A Priori
    Aquinas
    Article
    Assisted Dying
    Banking
    Bertrand Russell
    Book Review
    Buddhism
    Christianity
    Cosmological
    Covenant
    Dawkins
    Debate
    Design
    Diaspora
    Dig Deeper
    Dukkha
    Epiphany
    Equality
    Euthanasia
    Existentialism
    Fallacies
    False Dichotomy
    Family
    Fertility
    Genesis
    Hajj
    Higher Education
    Hindu
    Hinduism
    Holocaust
    Hospice
    Human Rights
    Human-rights
    Hume
    Islam
    ISRSA
    Judaism
    Justice
    JWT
    Lent
    Life After Death
    Love
    Martyr
    Messiah
    MOOC
    Narnia
    NDE
    News
    Nirvana
    Ontological
    Plato
    PPE
    Pro Choice
    Pro-Choice
    Pro Life
    Pro-Life
    Prophet
    Reformation
    Relativism
    Religion
    Rights
    Sabbath
    Science Vs Religion
    Secularisation
    Soul
    Sport
    Stewardship
    Surrogacy
    Teleological
    Temple
    Ten Commandments
    Theology
    Viability
    Via Negativa
    Vision
    Warfare
    Wittgenstein
    Word
    Word Of The Week
    Word-of-the-week

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos from sneakerdog, Steve Slater (Wildlife Encounters), Art4TheGlryOfGod, johndillon77, dustinj, Charlie Davidson, ineffable_pulchritude, LisaW123, jamee.khairul, Abode of Chaos, Dunleavy Family